Halloween Horror Nights, now in its 33rd year, has weaved tomes of terrifying tales for decades. These scary stories take place across different locations and even different dimensions. With decades of narratives told, it’s unsurprising that some, such as Shadybrook Rest Home and Sanitarium (which is directly tied to fan favorite icon Jack the Clown), have become common haunts within the event’s lore. However, there is one setting that has become a staple of the event: the township of Carey, Ohio.
Although it may seem like a fairly nondescript town, Carey has been something of a spool of just about every tale woven into the fabric of HHN. Icons like Jack the Clown and The Caretaker have roots in Carey, Ohio, as do the event’s mainstay butcher shop, Meetz Meats. Carey, Ohio is so deeply rooted within HHN lore that the event dedicated a house in 2021, Welcome to SCarey: Horror in the Heartland, to some of the fictitious township’s most notable houses and scare zones from years past.
So, what is it about this quaint little town that binds it to so much horror? Such a question prompted us to look into Carey’s ties to Halloween Horror Nights by building a timeline via the backstories of past houses, scare zones, and event icons. Before we do, we’ll remind you that Halloween Horror Nights 33 will run on select nights from August 30 through November 3. Remember to secure your discounted single-night tickets from Orlando Informer to make sure you and your entire scream squad are prepared.
Now then, let’s uncover the mysteries of Carey, Ohio.
Carey, Ohio – From Carae to SCarey
The fictitious township is named after its real-world counterpart, the hometown of a member of Universal’s Art and Design team. When these creatives needed a location for a backstory, this member suggested his own hometown, and that was that. While the reason at the time was simple enough, the truth was that it made more sense than one might realize. Sure, a quaint village named after an honorable judge, home to just over 3,000 residents, might seem an unlikely base for horror stories. Yet, Ohio has not only been the setting for numerous horror movies but has also been home to some of America’s most notorious killers, making it the perfect backdrop for Halloween Horror Nights.
As we mentioned, just about everything in HHN lore can be connected to Carey, Ohio. Although it seems as if it’s always been a part of the event’s history, Carey was actually only first mentioned by name in the 2008 scare zone titled The Skoolhouse. This was a semi-sequel to the 2005 house simply titled Skool, which did not mention the township of Carey. However, a deeper look reveals a connection that dates back to the 16th century in Carae, France, which is the sister city of the Ohio township. This connection marks the gruesome origins of Carey’s ties to Halloween Horror Nights.
Carey, Ohio: 1500s – 1970s
Catacombs: Black Death Rising (2010)
In 1534 France, a viral plague ravaged the regions surrounding Paris and Marseilles. The outbreak was so great that a group of doctors deemed it necessary to quarantine the infected in the French Catacombs to contain the spread. While their efforts were noble in spirit, they couldn’t have been more wrong. Imprisoned against their will, the infected took to uprising, locking the doctors with them in the legendary catacombs for 500 years.
Five centuries later, the infected prisoners escaped. Having been trapped and suffering from the virus for so long, the doctors and townsfolk, both living and dead, had returned with a hunger for vengeance that knew no bounds.
Twisted Tradition (2018)
After the events in France, the first of many cases in America took place around 300 years later. The direct connection between France and America isn’t clear, but what is known is that German immigrants settled in the township of Carey, Ohio. Not long thereafter, a man named Ernst Meier restored an abandoned pumpkin farm to great success. Word was heard throughout Carey, and Ernst let the town know that they could harvest his pumpkins once Halloween came around. Just one thing — he needed help! As he was only one man, he employed the local children to whom he promised each a pumpkin as a reward.
The township was excited as this was the beginning of one of their newest traditions but grew worried after some time when their children hadn’t come home with their families’ reward. The concerned citizens took to Ernst’s farm and were horrified by what they witnessed. Ernst was chanting an unearthly incantation while stirring child-sized gourds filled with blood and pumpkin guts around a large bonfire. Enraged, the townsfolk overtook him in an attempt to rescue their kids. As punishment, they declared that he be burned at the stake for his misdeeds. Ernst let out a villainous, slow laugh before responding that his masters would appreciate their assistance in finishing the rites of his incantation. Despite his ominous warning, the townsfolk threw Ernst into the bonfire as he continued chanting before burning to death.
Unaware of what they had unleashed—and possibly originating Carey’s terrible curse—the townsfolk buried the gourds. Years passed as Ernst’s farm once again lay overgrown in the forest, and stories of creatures made from pumpkin, vine, and wood wandering its surroundings spread throughout the township. The creatures have been said to serve an ancient evil, seeking sacrifices for their otherworldly masters. Much like Ernst’s farm, this is often to great success.
The Skoolhouse (2008)
The first in a string of related events began in 1908 at Carey Elementary School when one of their teachers, Mary Worthington, went missing. If Mary’s name has a familiar ring to it, that’s because she’s directly connected to the icon, Bloody Mary. Worthington vanished after a prank orchestrated by the school groundskeeper, Aldridge Hesterson, and six students. The specifics of the prank are unclear, but the following morning, Carey Elementary’s Headmaster, Mr. Renshaw, opened the school the next day to a scene covered in blood and shattered glass.
Although a case of suspected murder was opened, Worthington’s body was never recovered. However, a strange energy began to overtake the school, and on Halloween, a seemingly possessed Mr. Renshaw and his usually respectful, well-behaved students went on a special field trip. Their mission: to teach the township of Carey a terrifying lesson in fear.
Were the two events related? Perhaps that’ll be revealed later, as this was hardly the end of Bloody Mary’s story.
The Orfanage: Ashes to Ashes (2010) and Cindy Caine
Most of the records of the 1920 tragedy at Good Harvest Orphanage have been lost to time due to a strange fire at the children’s home, but most of the tales seem to involve a child named Cindy Caine. Cindy was said to have had a difficult childhood as she was quiet and mostly shunned since her arrival at the orphanage. Over time, she discovered that she possessed pyrokinetic abilities, which enabled her to exact fiery revenge against those who had wronged her at Good Harvest. Harnessing her newfound powers, she burned Good Harvest to the ground, settling scores with its staff and orphans.
Cindy Caine’s story is both promising and unfortunate. She was meant to be an icon for both 2002’s Halloween Horror Nights: Islands of Fear and Halloween Horror Nights: Twenty Years of Fear in 2010. Unfortunately, she was replaced on both occasions. Later revelations disclosed that she is the daughter of Dr. Albert Caine, also known as The Caretaker, deepening her connection to Carey, Ohio. While the full extent of Good Harvest’s tragic story may remain shrouded in mystery, Cindy Caine continues to lurk within the darkest recesses of Carey and Halloween Horror Nights.
Afterlife: Death’s Vengeance (2013)
In 1933, the good residents of Carey, Ohio finally saw the end of serial killer, Bobby “The Blade” Guletta after five murderous months of terror. Between June and October, Guletta had slain 22 victims, displaying their remains prominently as if wanting his “trophies” to be found while ensuring that he never left enough clues to his whereabouts.
Guletta was eventually tracked down with the help of one of his attempted victims, Susan Snowdon. She escaped from the old sawmill where she was being held and where Guletta had already murdered others. Guletta, true to his inferred ego, was heard provoking the executing policeman to pull the switch before his execution.
Following his execution, Bobby Guletta’s fate was ultimately sealed in the afterlife, where he was eternally tormented by various demons and his long list of victims. Although this wicked story stands alone within the annals of Carey, Afterlife: Death’s Vengeance is a notable house mainly in part because it is the first non-comedic house to use 3-D technology and one of those that utilizes a revolving tunnel as part of its effects.
Leave it to Cleaver (2009)
In the 1950s, the first of many cases involved local hero Samuel Meetz. Sam gained notoriety over the years after inheriting his family’s business, Meetz Meats. After generations of success, the Great Depression took a hard toll on the butcher shop. Sam’s father, keen on keeping the family business intact, decided that the best course of action was a change in livestock.
The new meat was a hit, even granting Samuel Meetz with a pop-up booth, The Meetz Locker. The source, Carey’s various vagrants and riff-raff, was only known to the Meetz employees and select others, but no one complained! It proved to be addictively delicious, kept the streets clean and crime-free, and was a great way to be rid of any snoops finding their way to the Meetz factories.
Aside from the meat’s source, the strangest part about the Meetz Meats products is their odd effect when consumed. During a case at Universal Palace Theater, movie attendees found a severed finger in the establishment’s latest hot dog offerings produced by Meetz Meats. Reports claimed that after eating the refreshment, the patrons couldn’t stomach any non-meat foods and even became ravenous with hunger.
Since appearing in the Leave it to Cleaver house, Sam Meetz, Meetz Meats, and its mascot, Meaty Meetz, have reappeared various times over the years, making it a staple for both HHN and Carey’s lore. Mike Aiello, Universal Orlando Resort’s Senior Director of Entertainment and Creative Development and a key figure behind Halloween Horror Nights, originally portrayed Sam Meetz in the house’s queue video.
Dead Exposure (2008)
One case is so prominent that it caught the unwitting eye of Charlie McPherson. McPherson was a natural-born photographer who received his first camera at a young age from his father, Shawn. His love for the art grew, and he eventually found himself among the staff of New York’s Metropolis Tribune and, later, a freelance photographer who’d often work alongside Private Investigator Boris Shuster. During this time in his career, McPherson would see grisly images while taking photos whenever his camera flash would go off. The sights were so horrifying that it led him to the offices of Dr. Mary Agana who specialized in new, sometimes extreme, ways of treating fear.
While under her care, he was also treated for claustrophobia, and during one of his sessions, Dr. Agana placed him in an airtight box with his camera’s flash bulb, which projected the horrifying images on the box’s walls. The treatment? Either he faces his fears of both claustrophobia and the images, or he suffocates. Although Dr. Agana informed Charlie that he simply had to open the box’s lid to escape, his fear held such a grip on him that he slowly suffocated to death in the glass coffin.
What’s especially interesting is the underlying connection the two of them have. Charlie McPherson is the son of Shawn McPherson, who was one of the children involved in the disappearance of Mary Worthington — the grandmother of Dr. Mary Agana. Charlie’s death even had an odd effect on Dr. Agana as it provided her with an unexpected thrill. This led to her slowly going insane and killing other patients as a way of conquering her fear of death. Furthering the connection, it’s also believed that Mary Worthington may have been slowly possessing Dr. Agana via the possessions the latter inherited, such as silver jewelry and a music box. As for Charlie, his body had also disappeared, but his death wasn’t the end of his torment. He’d become trapped in a zombie apocalypse within the realm of reflections, where he’d eventually become a zombie himself.
Reflections of Fear (2008)
Charlie McPherson’s disappearance inevitably caught Boris Shuster’s interest. The further he dove into Dr. Agana’s past and her other missing patients, the more suspicious he became of her practice. Eventually, Boris became a patient of Dr. Agana to investigate her further. Each time he visited her office, he’d continuously find evidence of Dr. Agana experimenting on her patients, including Charlie. He also noticed that each time he visited her, Dr. Agana became increasingly younger, and she began talking to her music box.
As time went on, Dr. Agana began to become aware of Boris’ intentions, which prompted him to escape her as she attacked during their session. Boris attempted to return and arrest Agana with backup but couldn’t find her. What they did find was a shattered mirror in her office and signs of an attack.
Following the arrest attempt, it’s revealed that while Dr. Agana did die that day, she would join her ancestor as the entity Bloody Mary in the Mirror realm. The events that took place also prompted Boris Shuster to found the Legendary Truth. The mainstay collective in HHN lore would be responsible for investigating many other cases within the event — including the accidental release of Adaru, or Fear itself.
Wicked Growth: Realm of the Pumpkin (2021)
The last documented case in the 1950s is when Carey returns us to a pumpkin patch owned by Mr. Carver. Similar to Ernst, Carver was renowned in Carey for his pumpkins, which the township would harvest and carve every year for their Halloween celebrations. However, unknown to the township, evil was growing within the soils and vines of Carver’s farm, which was a reason Carver’s pumpkins had grown so plentiful and large.
A local witch, Grimalkin the Summoner, and her sister, Locasta, had been assisting their dark leader, the Pumpkin Lord, in his return. His time back with us was short-lived, but his days walking amongst the township of Carey were still gruesome. While it seems to be a somewhat isolated occurrence, it does bear a strong resemblance to the events of Twisted Traditions in that one can’t help wondering just how related this incident was to Ernst’s farm all those centuries ago.
Wicked Growth: Realm of the Pumpkin is noteworthy for many reasons. This house is linked to a brand new event icon, The Pumpkin Lord, and has also inadvertently introduced a cute new character, Lil’ Boo. Within the house was also a plethora of callbacks from years past, including tie-ins to the Caretaker and a connection to Slaughter Sinema’s Pumpkin Guts movie by way of the Mr. Carver character.
H.R. Bloodengutz Presents: Holidays of Horror (2011)
In the 1970s, Lady Luck, the shapeshifting icon for 2011’s Halloween Horror Nights, made her appearance in Carey, Ohio. The entity had made contact with Larry Kurtzberg, an actor who was desperate for his next big role, under the guise of his agent. She offered him the role of H.R. Bloodengutz, the host of Midnight Horror Show, a horror variety program produced in Carey’s WKNB studio. Given the choice between this small-town show or his agency no longer representing him, he took the clear choice.
As the show went on, Larry enveloped himself within the role in every way, even demanding that he only be referred to as his character. As his obsession progressed, his show became increasingly disturbing, affecting its ratings and ad revenue. This was noticed by WKNB producer John Reynolds, who regrettably informed Larry that the show had to be canceled. Upon hearing this, Kurtzenberg kidnapped Reynolds and the production crew of Midnight Horror Show, putting them through obscene and terrible torture resulting in the death of the WKNB producer.
Modern-day horror in Carey, Ohio
Screamhouse (2002), Screamhouse: Revisited (2003), Screamhouse: Resurrection (2006)
There are many occurrences in Carey that don’t contain a specific date but can be assumed to take place in modern times. The first of which concerns Shady Oaks Cemetery, run by Dr. Albert Caine, better known as The Caretaker, and his family. Rumors ran throughout Carey that the Caine family were a strange bunch. They were said to look of varying ages, with an implied question of them being undead due to connected stories involving zombies. It’s also said that they often experimented and entertained themselves with the corpses of the town’s loved ones, often dancing with them. This was confirmed by two teens who took it upon themselves to snoop on the family, stirring the townsfolk and prompting the police to begin an investigation.
In an angry rage, the families of Carey set fire to Shady Oaks Cemetery. Once the fire and smoke cleared, although Shady Oaks Cemetery was burned to the ground, the only remains that were found of the Caine family were supposedly that of Cindy. A long series of tunnels that seemed to stretch for miles outside the township were later found. While the question as to whether the Caine family escaped the fire, a research team was dispatched to investigate later reports of ghoulish voices, strange howls, and moans coming from the ruins of Shady Oaks.
It’s important to note that although Cindy’s story takes place much earlier in the lore, Cindy actually appears twice here (officially and unofficially). In HHN 2003’s Screamhouse: Revisited, Cindy appears in the house’s kitchen scene with another character believed, but never confirmed to be, her unnamed brother. She’d later have her first official appearance in the 2006 sequel house, Screamhouse: Resurrection.
The Spawning (2009)
On a night like any other, a group of teenagers were seeing a movie at Universal Palace Theater. A few of them had gotten in trouble with the theater staff for being rowdy during the flick, which led to them all being kicked out and banned. Sometime later, they snuck back into the theater via the emergency exit on the night of their prom and were never seen again. Following reports of them missing, the police found no evidence of them in any part of the Palace Theater — until something prompted them to search the sewers under the building.
What they found was something out of a horror movie as they encountered a scene of torn and bloodied prom tuxedos that belonged to the teenagers. Their whereabouts remain a mystery, but all evidence led to foul play. Since then, locals of Wyandot County called in sightings of two-foot tall, snake-like creatures they’ve named “Sculders” within the sewers. A group of volunteers were sent to investigate reports of something tampering with the county’s water flow. Was this related to the Sculders? Only they would know for sure.
In addition to The Spawning’s setting of Wyandot County, the house’s first scene is identical to Dead Exposure, which provides a deeper connection to Carey’s influence in the event. This house would also be one of those revisited in Welcome to SCarey: Horror in the Heartland.
Legendary Truth: The Wyandot Estate (2010)
Years after their establishment, The Legendary Truth branched off to a smaller faction, the Spirit Seekers. Their biggest case brought them to the Wyandot Estate, a home built by Malcolm and Lydia Wyandot. The elaborate home served as the setting for a dinner party in which Malcolm brutally killed his thirteen guests, his wife, and himself on October 30, 1929.
Decades later, the township would tell stories of their ghosts haunting the decrepit Wyandot Estate, prompting the Spirit Seekers to investigate using a machine to summon the ghosts. What they received was more than they’d anticipated, as the tortured souls brought with them terrible violence. While there were some survivors of the resulting spiritual encounter, the main crew of the Spirit Seekers hasn’t been seen since.
Legendary Truth: The Wyandot Estate was another house revisited in a portion of Welcome to SCarey. Even more interesting, however, cameras were installed at portions of Legendary Truth: The Wyandot Estate, providing live cyber feeds of each night’s scares.
Lunatic’s Playground 3D (2016)
Over a few years, Carey continued to face some hardships involving disappearing teens at Carey’s Hartford Mansion in 2012 and a derailed convoy train carrying mutant soldiers in 2013. However, one case takes prominence as it involves Chance, Jack Schmidt’s sadistic assistant. After over a decade of horror, Jack had been returned to his box imprisonment, and Chance was committed to Shady Brook Rest Home and Sanitarium. As fate would have it, Chance escaped her holdings and began reaping havoc within Shady Brook. Although she was eventually recaptured, it didn’t come without casualties of both patients and staff.
Halloween Horror Nights 17 and Lunatic’s Playground are especially noteworthy because Chance took the role of that year’s icon. The house provided us with a great portrayal of Chance’s blurred reality while at Shady Brook. It also helped add more to the ever-expanding story of her and Jack within HHN lore as it told what happened directly after Halloween Horror Nights 25. It even showed us that Chance was more than Jack’s mere sidekick and worthy of being an event icon.
Slaughter Sinema (2018) and The Carey Drive-In
The Carey Drive-In theater had been closed to the public for years with good reason. Tragically, it became the murder site of movie patrons in its early years, causing it to be shut down. Decades later, in 2015, after reports of strange activity at the movie theater, a brave few were drawn in to investigate, only to discover their favorite horror movies were coming to life — literally! It was lights, camera, and carnage as they would find their fate sealed in cinematic blood. While the source of this has never been confirmed, one only wonders if there was truly someone behind this or the theater itself.
Three years later, the theater returned to life, seemingly hungry for more bodies. This time luring locals in with the promise of B movie showings, a movie type that had become popular with the times. Patrons flooded the theater to catch films like Pumpkin Guts, Cult of the Beast Baby, and Barber Chop only to realize that, once again, the movies had sprung to life from the flickering screens! While the fate of the theater’s victims was certainly tragic, it’s worth noting that the plots of each movie seem to resemble much of Carey’s history. One has to wonder just how much of it is truly fiction and how much of it is telling the story of days gone by.
When it comes to the Carey Drive-In theater, it’s been a landmark in Carey, Ohio since 2015 with the scare zone, All Nite Die-In: Double Feature, and returned in house form in Slaughter Sinema. This house was especially entertaining and groundbreaking for multiple reasons. The movie posters preceding each section of the house featured numerous references to past icons such as The Caretaker and Jack Schmidt. Additionally, the set for Barber Chop was located in Morton Meetz’s Barber Shop. Does that name sound familiar? Additionally, its Attack of the Swamp Yeti portion was also responsible for inspiring the Yeti: Terror of the Yukon house in 2019.
Many of these houses were revisited in HHN 2021’s Welcome to SCarey: Horror in the Heartland. 2024 will mark another return to the Carey Drive-In with Slaughter Sinema 2, a sequel to Slaughter Sinema. Those like this writer are especially excited to see what’s in store.
The township of Carey, Ohio, is such a recurring location in HHN lore that one wonders what we haven’t uncovered. Indeed, horror has found a home in the fog and shadows of the heartland.
Learn more about Halloween Horror Nights in our insider’s guide, then discuss it all with 170,000+ other Universal die-hard fans in our Orlando Informer Community on Facebook. And be sure to follow Orlando Informer on TikTok, Threads, Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram for the latest news, tips, and more at Universal Orlando, Walt Disney World, and other Orlando attractions.
